Developing Story
Louisiana AG Refuses Judge’s Apology Demand In LSU-SEC Case
Liz Murrill says a federal judge cannot compel Louisiana to express regret. The disputed wording will be removed, but the refusal opens a new fight over compliance and possible sanctions.
BATON ROUGE, La. — Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill did not give a federal judge the apology she wanted Wednesday. She gave her a challenge.
Hours after U.S. District Judge Annemarie Carney Axon told lawyers representing LSU and Louisiana to retract disputed language and prepare public statements expressing regret, Murrill said she would not apologize.
“I cannot and will not apologize for my lawyers doing their job, and it is improper for an Alabama federal judge to compel speech from the State of Louisiana.”
“The SEC made an egregious citation error. Their inability to explain that error is their problem, not Louisiana’s.”
Murrill’s office said it filed a response in Southeastern Conference v. Rousse, the SEC’s federal lawsuit against LSU officials and members of the LSU Board of Supervisors.
The complete filing was not available on the publicly accessible docket Wednesday afternoon. No written order memorializing Axon’s instructions from the bench had appeared there, either. The latest publicly listed entry remained the order setting Wednesday’s hearing.
According to WBRZ, Murrill said Louisiana would remove the disputed wording from its earlier filing. She also asked the court to release Birmingham attorney Bruce Rogers from the case, saying he should not suffer “collateral consequences” from the dispute.
That request has not been granted.
How The Fight Started
The confrontation grew out of an LSU filing that said SEC citations appeared to have been “negligently supplied or hallucinated.” The SEC asked Axon to strike the language or allow the conference to file a limited sur-reply defending its use of the cases.
During Wednesday’s hearing, Rogers acknowledged that the cases were real. He argued that the SEC had misstated what the cases held.
Axon rejected his attempt to explain “hallucinated” as a criticism of the SEC’s legal reasoning. She said the wording attacked the professional reputation of the SEC’s lawyers and reflected poor judgment.
Axon allowed LSU to seek permission to replace the page containing the accusation. She also allowed the SEC to respond to the dispute over the three cases.
No sanctions were imposed Wednesday. Axon warned Rogers that another incident could produce sanctions “to the fullest extent” available to her, according to courtroom reporting.
What Murrill’s Refusal Changes
Murrill’s refusal leaves the court with another decision: whether to accept removal of the wording without the public expression of regret Axon demanded, issue a written order or take further action against the lawyers or parties.
LSU has not separately said it will refuse Axon’s request. Murrill’s statement speaks for her office and Louisiana’s legal position. It should not be described as a separate LSU statement unless the university issues one.
Still Unresolved
- LSU’s motion to dismiss the SEC’s federal lawsuit.
- Whether the SEC can discipline LSU or enforce its eligibility policies against the university.
- Whether the federal court has jurisdiction over the remaining dispute.
- RJ Luis’ eligibility and the Baton Rouge preliminary injunction protecting him and LSU.
- Whether Axon will respond to Murrill’s refusal with a written order or further proceedings.
None of Wednesday’s developments resolved the larger lawsuit.
Axon did not rule on LSU’s motion to dismiss. She did not decide whether the SEC can discipline LSU, whether the conference can enforce its eligibility policies against the university or whether the federal court has jurisdiction over the remaining dispute.
She also did not decide RJ Luis’ eligibility. Luis remains protected by the preliminary injunction issued in Baton Rouge state court unless that order is stayed, reversed or otherwise changed.
The federal case now has two fights moving at once. One concerns the SEC’s authority over LSU and the court’s power to hear the case. The other concerns Louisiana’s refusal to make the public statement Axon requested.
Louisiana has agreed to remove the disputed words. It has not agreed to express regret for using them.
Source documents and reporting: Federal docket · Murrill response report

Be the first to comment