Paul Finebaum Says He Doesn’t Know Whether LSU Is Better Under Lane Kiffin

Paul Finebaum and Lane Kiffin
Paul Finebaum (left) questioned Lane Kiffin’s coaching on Tiger Rag Radio but said he did not know whether LSU had improved under Kiffin. (Photos: ESPN Press Room; LSU Athletics)

Todd Horne Column

Finebaum Questioned Kiffin’s Coaching. He Couldn’t Say Whether LSU Has Improved.

Paul Finebaum watched Lane Kiffin’s Monday press conference, two days after LSU lost to Texas, and called him a “broken man” on national television.

On Tiger Rag Radio Tuesday, I asked Finebaum whether that description came from measured football judgment or from the kind of “going for broke” television opinion he has discussed before. He rejected the suggestion that he needed attention. He said he was reacting to what he saw and heard from Kiffin.

Finebaum has every right to criticize the press conference. Kiffin was visibly upset. LSU had lost another game it had a chance to win. At 6–4, the Tigers have fallen well short of the expectations that came with his hiring.

Finebaum went further, though. He said he now has to ask whether Kiffin is a great coach.

That calls for an examination of the football program. I gave Finebaum LSU’s year-over-year numbers and asked whether the program is better now than it was a year ago.

“I’ll just be very blunt. I don’t know. I cover college football from 38,000 feet.”

He was candid. He also acknowledged that people who cover LSU closely may know more about this team than he does.

Here is what a closer look shows. LSU is averaging roughly 157 more yards and 13 more points per game on offense than it did last season. It is gaining about 69 more rushing yards per game. The defense is allowing about 66 fewer yards per game. LSU has recorded 40 sacks through 10 games, compared with 27 in 13 games last season.

Those figures do not excuse four losses. They do show substantial improvement in the work a football coach is hired to do.

Kiffin is responsible for the way LSU has finished games. The Tigers have squandered opportunities, made costly mistakes and lost games they could have won. I have said so on the air and in print. If those failures continue, they will define his tenure regardless of what the yardage says.

But this is his first season, and the program is better than the one he inherited. Anyone questioning his ability as a football coach ought to examine that evidence alongside the losses.

Finebaum offered a reason for judging Kiffin harshly. LSU pursued him aggressively, paid him accordingly and brought him to Baton Rouge with enormous fanfare. Finebaum believed the Tigers had a reasonable shot at the playoff. From that starting point, 6–4 is a letdown. I agree.

A disappointing season and a better program can exist at the same time. So can an ugly press conference and good coaching. Finebaum’s criticism of Kiffin’s demeanor may be justified; his doubts about Kiffin’s football ability require more work than he had done when I asked him.

Finebaum did not claim otherwise. He said he didn’t know whether LSU had improved because he watches from 38,000 feet.

From there, the losses are easy to see. So is Kiffin at a microphone on a bad Monday. The gains in the offense, defense and roster require a closer look. Before deciding whether Kiffin can coach, Finebaum should take one.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*


+ forty four = 52
Powered by MathCaptcha