REYNOLDS: Tigers Refused to Throw in the Towel
While many weren’t overly enthused with the Chick-fil-A Bowl, it was a must-win for Les Miles and the Tigers
by Matt Reynolds
Tiger Rag Assistant Editor
(At left) LSU running back Charles Scottscored three touchdowns in the Tigers’ 38-3 rout of Georgia Tech. (Photo by Steve Franz/LSU)
When the official announcement in mid-December came out pairing LSU with Georgia Tech in the Chick-fil-A Bowl, the feeling of the outcome of this game was overwhelmingly unanimous from Baton Rouge clear down to Peachtree Street.
In fact, the majority of college football fans and so-called experts thought they had this one pegged a cool 20 days before the teams took the field.
I received an email a couple of weeks ago from a portly fellow we’ll call “Nostrodamus from Swinetown” that read: “As if LSU wasn’t embarrassed enough in Little Rock by a far less talented team, Georgia Tech is going to make Les Miles wish he would have taken the offer from the boys in Ann Arbor.” And for what it’s worth, I still wonder why people send me emails like this, as if I work on LSU’s coaching staff or something.
Anyway, it seems as if it were written in the stars. Georgia Tech was going to feast on the battered and broken LSU Tigers like a pack of dire wolves on a gang of poodles.
As it turns out, the hammer and not a ball was dropped in Atlanta on New Years Eve. But it was the Rambling Wreck that was on the wrong end of the slaughter.
With LSU leading 35-3 at halftime, ESPN College Gameday analyst Lou Holtz made an interesting point. The former Notre Dame head coach said that there were a couple of statistics that nobody was talking about before this game and one of them was that LSU had beaten ACC schools in 17 straight contests.
But it was easy to overlook that statistic if you look at what Georgia Tech was able to do with its option attack during the regular season or if you had seen how completely lost LSU’s defense looked all season long. And lets be honest, most of the nation witnessed the debacle that was LSU’s title defense this season, as the Tigers were a cool 0-5 on nationally televised CBS games this season. The curse of the Gary Danielson!
Here are several things that contributed to LSU’s surprise 38-3 drumming of the Yellow Jackets:
1. The embarrassment factor.
While there were a number of low points throughout the season, the Friday after Thanksgiving in Little Rock was, for lack of a better phrase, rock bottom for LSU. Some of the players were angry, some shocked and some seemed just ready for the nightmare to be over. At this time, it appeared to be a strong sense of disenchantment and division on the LSU team and many people started to question if the Tigers had punched the clock after the loss to Alabama in early November.
So for over an entire month this LSU team, less than a year removed from a BCS National Title, had to hear how much of a disappointment they were. And throw in the fact that they were a colossal underdog in the public’s eyes against Georgia Tech, and just maybe that must have motivated the talented bunch from Baton Rouge.
Linebacker Perry Riley, who earned defensive MVP honors in the game said, “We played with an energy that we haven’t played with all year.”
That’s an understatement Perry.
It could have been that the Tigers were playing at supersonic speed that night, but Tech’s option ground game looked like they were running through a tar pit.
2. It was a must win for Miles.
We all know that in the modern age of football, it’s all about “what have you done for me lately.”
Forget the fact that Les Miles has a record of 42-11 during his time at LSU and has produced two SEC western division titles (2005,2007), one SEC championship (2007) and one BCS crystal ball (2007). With five losses in the regular season and a coaching staff blunder that led to the Tigers having the worst defense in the SEC this year, Miles was feeling pressure that I’m sure he never could have imagined possible back before the ’08 season began.
It didn’t help that former LSU coach Nick Saban lead SEC west foe Alabama to an undefeated regular season and pulled out the victory in his homecoming to Baton Rouge in November.
It’s no secret, the purple and gold nation was questioning if their coach was a man that could stop the fiasco before the wheels completely dismantled beneath the program.
This win was crucial for LSU, but more importantly it showed that Miles could get a 7-5 team up off the mat and deliver a knockout punch in the 13th round and keep his bowl record a flawless 4-0 at LSU.
3. LSU had their quarterback.
Some point to the defense as the catalyst to the disastrous conference play this year. Sure, that was a huge problem, but the quarterback play should take the brunt of the blame.
We all know the story by now about how and why Jarrett Lee was forced into the starting quarterback role. But what is still unclear is why in the name of everything that is sacred did the coaching staff not play Jordan Jefferson earlier in the season?
It would be easier to dismiss if Lee was setting the world on fire, but he was actually setting the scoreboard on fire, but for the wrong team.
Jordan Jefferson was the only other option for most of the season, after Andrew Hatch broke his leg in the Georgia game, so how did someone not see that Jefferson was the better option when watching him at practice?
He’s more athletic, stronger, durable, and mobile. And makes better decisions or at least that’s what it looked like on game day.
It took Lee getting knocked out of the game against what we now know is a stellar Ole Miss team, to see Jefferson getting thrown into the mix. Even then, it was obvious that Lee’s days could be numbered as LSU’s quarterback. Now it is crystal clear.
What the true freshman did against Georgia Tech was the same thing he did every time he was given a chance this season. He didn’t cripple his team with his mistakes.
But the difference in the Chick-fil-A Bowl than Jefferson’s previous two games was that there was over a month where the coaching staff fully focused on preparing him as far as the playbook is concerned.
The results were the same. Instead of hurting the team, he improved it. And the rest of the team responded to his leadership.
Could that have been the problem all along?
—
Matt Reynolds is the assistant editor of Tiger Rag. Reach him at mattreynolds@tigerrag.com.





Great article! During the season Coach Miles said Jefferson wasn’t an SEC caliber quarterback, but he failed to notice neither was Jarrett Lee. I felt that midway during the season Coach Miles should have given Jefferson a chance to see what he could do and not just one series a game. One series doesn’t give a quarterback a chance to get into the flow of the game. Again great article!
This was a very good article. What I don’t understand is how everyone in the world, from TV announcers to ex players to the worst fan knew that Jefferson should have been given some earlier playing time, but our coaches didn’t realize it. Even if Lee were setting the world on fire, you still have to have another guy ready even if your preference is to red shirt him. I admit that I wouldn’t want a million people evaluating my job performance every week-end, but I’m not a college coach making 4 mil. It didn’t take a rocket scientist to realize what needed to be done.
Love the article, nice job! However, I think we need not look back in hindsight and think that this team could have been much better with Jefferson running the show. We may have picked up 1 or 2 more wins (Alabama and maybe Georgia), but the other losses (Florida, Ole Miss, and Arkansas) would probably not been avoidable with Jefferson even if he had been playing more earlier in the season.
Let’s all remember 2 plays in the Georgia Tech game that worked our well for Jefferson. First, the officials missed the call on the fumble that Jefferson had which was called an incomplete pass. Georgia Tech took that fumble back for a touchdown. Jefferson fumbled again in the endzone and if not for a heads-up play by Richard Murphy, it could have easily been 6 for Tech. Tech was also their own worst enemy. They missed a fake punt on their own 22. They muffed a punt which was recovered by LSU deep in Tech territory and they missed a 4th and short on their own side of the field.
I think Tech should have made LSU drive the field 80+ yds each time and make Jefferson beat you. I think Jefferson has some skills. He threw the ball better than he has all year, but he is still raw. He holds the ball too long which will happen with QBs who can make stuff happen with their feet. He also has a fairly slow release with cause problems in the future.
Let’s all remember Jefferson is a work in progress and have some games in 2009 that look very ‘Lee-like’. If we all understand we might get some bad with hopefully a lot more good, then we will be OK.
Personally I am excited about John Chavis and some of the defensive changes. Our defense was terrible in 2008. We have way too much talent to be that bad. I think the reason Chavis and Cooper are excited to come to LSU is there is no where to go put up with the defense. Look for LSU to be at the top of the SEC next year on D. And if LSU’s defense can be that good, we can definitely swallow some pick sixes and shakey play from our still very young QBs.
It is easy to play field general in hindsight, but it’s not so easy to use insight. Many fans seem to forget some big factors in why it took JJ so long to see significant playing time. On the surface, Lee has all the tools to be a good QB. He was an Elite 11 QB which is a huge accomplishment at the high school level. And despite his infamous pick 6s, he made some very good and accurate throws early in the season. I think by the end of the season, the pressure and inexperience caught up with him and he lost his confidence.
Also, Miles was trying to redshirt JJ. And while Lee was looking so bad by the end of the season, JJ was still an unproven commodity. So there wasn’t much of an option until Lee was injured. Had Miles known that Perrilloux, Lee, and Hatch would all be unavailable to play, I’m sure JJ would have gotten many more reps earlier in the season.
Charlie, you are a wise man. JJ has still not seen nearly as many games as Lee, so there is no guarantee that he is the better QB. I think he has the most potential, but he will have growing pains too. I do agree that he has earned the right to be the starter in the spring.
Fans are too quick to judge coaches. This is why turnover is so great and coaching loyalty seems to be rare. I suggest that those of you who are so angry at Miles for his lack of foresight pick up a whistle and get out on the field. Otherwise, get another hobby.
As Rohan Davey (now Jordan Jefferson) once said to the LSU team upon entering the Peach Bowl 2000 in the Third Quarter, if everone stays cool we are going to win this game, LSU rolls.